“We Must Talk To Al Qaeda”
Guardian:
Top Blair aide: Former No 10 chief says Irish peace process showed link to enemy needed
Western governments must talk to terror groups including al-Qaida and the Taliban if they hope to secure a long-term halt to their campaigns of violence, according to the man who for more than a decade was Tony Blair’s most influential aide and adviser.
Jonathan Powell, who served as Blair’s chief of staff from 1995 to 2007 and is widely regarded as having been instrumental in negotiating a settlement in Northern Ireland, said his experience in the province convinced him that it was essential to keep a line of communication open even with one’s most bitter enemies.
Powell said: “There’s nothing to say to al-Qaida and they’ve got nothing to say to us at the moment, but at some stage you’re going to have to come to a political solution as well as a security solution. And that means you need the ability to talk.”
In his first major interview, ahead of the publication of his book on the behind the scenes drama leading to the Northern Ireland peace deal, Powell also delivered a remarkably candid assessment of the Blair years, revealing that:
· He did not think Labour had governed boldly enough because it feared losing power.
· Blair had a tendency to change his mind about things and could be “a bit of a flippertygibbet”.
· Blair had failed in 10 years of government to sell Europe to the British.
· Relations between the Blair and Brown camps were so toxic that Gordon Brown did not talk to him for 10 years.
Powell, the most senior member of the Blair circle to survive the prime minister’s full term in office, said that he had realised, after reviewing government papers and his diaries, that a secret back channel between the British government and the IRA, first opened in the 1970s, was one of the key factors that contributed to a peace deal three decades later.
“It’s very difficult for democratic governments to do - talk to a terrorist movement that’s killing your people,” he said. “[But] if I was in government now I would want to have been talking to Hamas, I would be wanting to communicate with the Taliban; and I would want to find a channel to al-Qaida.”
Powell’s remarks will be highly controversial, as all western governments have insisted any contact with al-Qaida would be immoral and pointless. A spokesman for the Foreign Office said last night: “It is inconceivable that HMG would ever seek to reach a mutually acceptable accommodation with a terrorist organisation like al-Qaida.”
The government’s position on the Taliban and Hamas has been more nuanced: it did communicate with the Palestinian group for a period through an MI6 officer, but broke off contact and now insists Hamas must recognise Israel and end violence before talks can resume. In December Brown ruled out talking to the Taliban leadership, but said he would “support [Afghanistan’s] President Karzai in his efforts at reconciliation”.
Powell, whose book, Great Hatred, Little Room, will be serialised exclusively in the Guardian from Monday, conceded that the idea of talking to al-Qaida and the Taliban was fraught with practical problems: “Who do you talk to? And what do you actually have to talk about?”
Reflecting on Blair’s time in office, Powell said ministers had been slow to act in many areas because “we were mesmerised by the notion that we’d be another Labour government that came in, a flash in the pan, and then disappeared again … And so the huge emphasis was on not spending all our political capital, hoarding it and saving it to win another election and stay in power”.
He said that Labour’s first term in office had also been hampered by the poor calibre of many ministers, including the health secretary Frank Dobson, whom he described as “a disaster”, and the environment minister Michael Meacher.
Although he said he believed Blair had increased Britain’s influence in Europe, one of his biggest regrets was that the government had failed to sell Europe at home. “We didn’t manage to change British attitudes about Europe … Tony made lots of speeches, but we never could do that.”
Powell also offered a remarkable insight into the intensity of the years-long Blair-Brown feud, revealing that the former chancellor had walked past him weekly for more than 10 years without ever saying hello.
Periodically, he said, he could hear the two men yelling at each other through the door of the prime minister’s office.
Though he said he regarded Blair as a “remarkable, visionary leader” who would go down as one of the greatest British prime ministers, he conceded that he found some of his personality traits irritating, in particular his habit of “not sticking to things once you’d decided them”.
He said: “I take a very strong view, once you’ve decided to do something you should really stick to it and see it through and he would sometimes be a bit of a flippertygibbet about things and change his mind.”
Note: LONDON, March 15, (RTRS): The Foreign Office on Saturday dismissed as “inconceivable” calls by an ex-aide to former British Prime Minister Tony Blair to open a channel of communication with al-Qaeda.
Be respectful of others and their opinions. Inflammatory remarks and inane leftist drivel will be deleted. It ain’t about free speech, remember you’re in a private domain. My website, my prerogative.
If you can't handle using your real email address, don't bother posting a comment.
God, I’ve had it with these “lets talk” Oprah Libs!
March 16th, 2008 at 11:24 amJonathan Powell … have at it, mate.
I think you should go and meet with them … personally.
March 16th, 2008 at 11:35 amWe SHOULD talk to our enemies! Here’s what we should say:
“Die, Abdullah!”
Then we kill them.
Conversation concluded.:eek:
March 16th, 2008 at 12:06 pmWe see what ‘talk’ has done for the UK and it’s Muslims.
March 16th, 2008 at 12:15 pmDon’t they get it, the Irish never wanted to destroy the entirety of Western society.
Will these Progressive fools never learn?
March 16th, 2008 at 12:35 pmThis hurts my head. alqueeeda is not looking for peaceful coexistence. Their honor code touts lying to your enemies. What the f*ck good will words do with these savages? Ever try and sell anything to a hajji? They lie from start to finish, negotiations are a charade. His blunt ignorance is amazing.
Ever see the ‘96 film Mars Attacks?
March 16th, 2008 at 12:41 pmEver see the ‘96 film Mars Attacks?
“Why can’t we just get along?”
March 16th, 2008 at 12:49 pmFuck Al-Qaeda and Fuck you aide
March 16th, 2008 at 12:52 pmSteve -
“Mars Attacks” … Great American classic
You would have much better success trying to talk to a cobra or a rabid dog than trying to talk to A.Q.
I am certain Catholic Archbishop Paulos Faraj Rahho “talked” to A.Q. … calmly, peacefully, patiently, and for a long time … before they killed him.
March 16th, 2008 at 1:07 pmJonathan Powell = Nevelle Chamberlin.
March 16th, 2008 at 1:41 pmBlue Oval, Steve in NC, that was the big difference. From what I saw from the backwater talks was that the IRA agreed to call in the bombings to Scotland Yard before they set off the bomb so as to not harm innocent civilians. Lord Mountbattan was targeted because the military and the Royals were fair game. With the islamists everything is fair game anytime, anywhere.
March 16th, 2008 at 1:46 pmTalk to Al Qaeda, sounds like Obama to me.
March 16th, 2008 at 1:48 pmApparently Jonathan can no longer “tell a hawk from a handsaw.”
Superficially similar labels do not constitute grounds for similar treatment, Johnny.
March 16th, 2008 at 2:26 pmLet the 50 cal. do the talkin.
March 16th, 2008 at 2:42 pmTalk to AQ? I don’t think so. AQ can only be killed, not talked to…it is pretty simple, you nitwit fuck!
March 16th, 2008 at 2:43 pmTALK!!..talk to my Ass you Fucktard!!
March 16th, 2008 at 5:18 pmLook how well the talks between Hamas and Israel is working out. Its an all time love fest at the Gaza strip and the West Bank.
March 16th, 2008 at 10:58 pmTwo key words in there,
1) Guardian - anything that lefty rag prints can be iignored
2) Former - ie. no longer has power.
FWIW, The British Labour (sic) Party now has the lowest poll rating
March 17th, 2008 at 1:18 amin 25 years and if they had an election today the Conservatives
would trounce them.